-
Sustainability challenges with international trad

The evolving sustainability landscape

Supply chains and scope 3 challenges.

Jaya Vohra discusses a number of sustainability challenges with international trade experts. Key themes include rising regulatory pressures, challenges in data collection and the need for cross industry collaboration to foster meaningful change.

Emily Farrimond
Partner, ESG and Sustainability Lead, Financial Services, Baringa Partners

Encarna Mateos
Head of Quality, Environment and Energy, Sacyr Spain

Richard Tarboton
Managing Director, Head of Sustainability Strategy and Policy, Barclays

Data capture is vital for enhancing transparency in the supply chain, and tech companies are instrumental in this aspect.

Jaya Vohra

Managing Director, Global Head of Trade and Working Capital Product and Client Management, Barclays

Driving efforts around supply chains and scope 3 emissions

Sustainability continues to rise up the agenda for companies for a number of reasons. Global regulations, particularly in climate and sustainability, are driving momentum. In Europe, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) will require comprehensive reporting across environmental, social and governance (ESG) aspects, influencing companies’ strategies.

Emily Farrimond suggested that initially, businesses focused on direct emissions, scopes 1 and 2, but are now shifting attention to indirect emissions, scope 3, which can comprise up to 80% of total emissions for many organisations. Given its significance, addressing scope 3 is pivotal for any net-zero target or strategy.

Companies are grappling with calculating scope 3 and identifying hotspots at supplier and category levels. The challenge lies in gathering vast amounts of data from a wide variety of different suppliers across the supply chain.

Emily Farrimond

Partner, ESG and Sustainability Lead, Financial Services, Baringa Partners

Regulation is a key driving force. Companies are increasingly adopting science-based targets that require coverage of their scope 3 emissions if they are material. In fact, over a third of the total market capitalisation of companies in the world – measured on their total market value – has committed to setting such targets through the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi).

Richard Tarboton added that businesses have made tremendous progress, with more and more companies signing up to set targets and communicate the information that’s required by their investors, stakeholders and supply chains about what their emissions are and how they are improving on them over time.

Encarna Mateos noted that the main problem that Sacyr face in advancing scope 3, is often the lack of experience throughout the value chain, resulting in a lack of transparency in the information reported.

We have an extensive network of more than 20,000 suppliers and subcontractors, which makes our supply chains very complex. Around 80% of our activities, including services and materials procurement, are outsourced. While scope 1 and 2 calculations are currently mandatory in many countries, there’s a rising emphasis on scope 3. Scope 1, 2 and 3 need to take on the same level of reporting and commitment.

Encarna Mateos

Head of Quality, Environment and Energy, Sacyr Spain

Measuring scope 3 emissions

Scope 3 encompasses all emissions from a company’s suppliers and customers, including those generated in the production and use of goods and services throughout the supply chain. Richard Tarboton stated that if you operate an agricultural supply chain business selling food, all emissions stemming from farming activities, including those from tractors, machinery, soil management and crop cultivation, contribute to your scope 3 emissions. You can imagine that it gets quite complicated.

This complexity is compounded by geographic dispersion, with supply chains spanning multiple countries. That’s the first difficulty, and the reason why scope 3 is so challenging; the sheer volume and complexity of the data to collect and analyse is vast.

Richard Tarboton

Managing Director, Head of Sustainability Strategy and Policy, Barclays

The second key issue is engagement and control. While you have direct control over enhancing energy efficiency within your own operations through investments and installations, influencing emissions within the supply chain is more indirect. Emily Farrimond suggests that companies can exert some control through the contracts that are awarded, requiring suppliers to meet specific standards. However, these suppliers have their own supply chains, contributing indirectly to your scope 3 emissions.

Integrating sustainability-linked financing into sustainability strategies

The essence of sustainability-linked financing lies in its role as a facilitative tool for engaging organisations on sustainability. Financiers use it to assess businesses against sustainable goals before lending. However, corporates must first establish their sustainability objectives, tailored to their specific sector and industry. This involves selecting relevant KPIs, such as emissions for energy companies or social metrics for textile factories, for example, ensuring a comprehensive approach across the entire supply chain.

To truly foster innovation throughout the supply chain, incentivisation plays a critical role. We’ve seen the structures evolve around supply chain financing where a large buyer sets KPIs for its entire supply chain to meet.

Jaya Vohra

Managing Director, Global Head of Trade and Working Capital Product and Client Management, Barclays

If the suppliers meet these KPIs, the buyer may offer pricing incentives or provide access to supply chain financing options. This illustrates the various methods by which large organisations incentivise and extend financing to their deep-tier supply chains. It’s also crucial for these organisations to support their suppliers in adhering to the set KPIs.

Encarna Mateos concludes by mentioning that another aspect of innovation revolves around digitalisation and the importance of data capture. It’s incredibly important to establish standards that enable everyone to evaluate sustainable targets consistently. When it comes to assessing KPIs, companies typically appoint an ESG-focused fintech to assign ESG scores. However, these entities often utilise their own methodologies, albeit based on common principles, leading to variations in assessment standards.

Your next steps

Insights

Grow your business

Want to know how to maximise your business potential? Read our latest insights on how to help your business grow.

Solutions

Corporate Banking Solutions

We provide a complete spectrum of solutions to enable your business to transact and trade easily, manage risks efficiently and finance its plans for growth.

Contact us

Get in touch

To discuss your business requirements and how Barclays can support you, contact us today.